Trudeau behind worst financial progress since Great Depression?

Article content material

A brand new report by the Fraser Institute on Canada’s financial progress illustrates the knowledge of the well-known saying popularized by Mark Twain that, “There are three sorts of lies: Lies, damned lies and statistics.”

Article content material

It argues that whereas the Justin Trudeau authorities was boasting about Canada’s sturdy financial progress throughout its final 5 years in energy from 2020-2024, the common Canadian’s way of life was plummeting by the steepest fee in any five-year interval for the reason that Great Depression.

Article content material

Article content material

The distinction within the competing claims is the Liberal authorities was citing annual will increase in Canada’s actual (inflation-adjusted) gross home product — largely due to its runaway immigration insurance policies.

Rapid and dramatic will increase in inhabitants enhance whole GDP as a result of extra items and companies are wanted to accommodate them.

But the underlying story, in response to the fiscally conservative Fraser Institute, was the unfavorable progress fee of actual GDP per particular person, a broadly accepted measure of nationwide prosperity and way of life.

Article content material

Article content material

The examine says that was adversely impacted by excessive immigration — as a result of the will increase surpassed the expansion fee of the economic system, resulting in a much bigger financial pie however a smaller slice for everybody, together with different authorities polices that led to weak enterprise funding, together with the financial uncertainty created by elevated laws, larger taxes and huge deficits by federal and provincial governments.

The examine — Canada’s ‘Ugly’ Growth Experience, 2020-2024: Why GDP Per Capita Declined While the Overall Economy Grew — warned Canada’s poor efficiency bodes in poor health for the long run.

Study co-author Lawrence Schembri stated it might imply the common Canadian’s way of life might be even decrease than a projection by the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development that Canada could have the worst report of financial progress per particular person among the many world’s 38 superior economies from 2020 to 2060.

Article content material

RECOMMENDED VIDEO

We apologize, however this video has did not load.

Play Video

The Fraser Institute says that whereas Canada’s GDP grew by a mean of 1.5% yearly, or 7.8% cumulatively, from 2020 to 2024, GDP per particular person fell by a mean of 0.4% yearly, or 2% cumulatively, over 5 years.

That was the worst report of any G7 nation (Canada, U.S., U.Okay., France, Italy and Japan) save for Germany, the examine stated, and weaker than different comparable nations, corresponding to Australia and New Zealand.

This whereas the Trudeau authorities, citing whole GDP numbers, was boasting about what it stated was Canada’s sturdy financial progress.

It’s not as if the Trudeau authorities didn’t find out about the issue.

One of the key inhibitors of financial progress per particular person is an absence of productiveness due to weak enterprise funding.

Article content material

Low productiveness doesn’t imply staff are lazy. It means companies aren’t investing in new applied sciences to extend their effectivity and productiveness.

That’s partly as a result of the Trudeau authorities’s runaway immigration insurance policies gave them easy accessibility to low cost labour as an alternative choice to rising effectivity, together with the financial uncertainty created by excessive taxation, excessive debt and onerous laws.

Prime Minister Mark Carney cited Trudeau’s excessive immigration insurance policies, together with out-of-control authorities operational spending, as two causes our economic system was in dangerous form earlier than U.S. President Donald Trump’s tariffs.

In March 2024, Carolyn Rogers, senior deputy governor of the Bank of Canada, known as low productiveness a “break the glass emergency” requiring an overhaul of financial insurance policies as a result of the established order was not an choice.

Article content material

Then-finance minister Chrystia Freeland described low productiveness because the “Achilles heel” of the Canadian economic system in her April 2022 funds speech, warning “we’re falling behind with regards to financial productiveness” and “productiveness issues as a result of it’s what ensures the dream of each guardian — that our youngsters might be extra affluent than we’re,” a dream dying in Canada at present.

Her funds cited the OECD projection that Canada’s GDP per particular person from 2020 to 2060 would develop on the slowest fee amongst chosen OECD nations and beneath the OECD common.

Writing in The Hub final yr, University of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe stated GDP per particular person in Canada had fallen to virtually half that within the U.S., including, “This gorgeous divergence is unprecedented in fashionable historical past.”

Article content material

To be truthful, the problem of low productiveness preceded the Trudeau authorities and was exacerbated by the 2020 pandemic that prompted labour shortages because the economic system started to recuperate, which was partly answerable for excessive immigration ranges that even Trudeau, finally, admitted have been a mistake.

But Trudeau doesn’t get a cross. During the 2015 election that introduced him to energy, he accused then-prime minster Stephen Harper of getting the worst report of financial progress of any Canadian authorities for the reason that Great Depression.

A decade later, Trudeau holds that doubtful title.

Article content material