Toronto’s two ineffective TTC transit traces ought to have been subways

Article content material

Back within the day when the Eglinton Crosstown and the Finch LRT had been twinkles within the eyes of politicians, I stated they need to be subways.

Article content material

Like the late Toronto Mayor Rob Ford, I believed in “subways, subways, subways.”

Article content material

Article content material

Why? The principal purpose is our winters.

The Finch LRT was barely open for a day or two final week once we had a small – by our requirements – snowfall. What occurred? The LRT snarled resulting from “climate associated incidents.” Thank you. I relaxation my case.

Take a have a look at the so-called “stations,” alongside the Eglinton LRT. At Pharmacy, it’s little greater than a bus shelter in the course of a six-lane freeway. What’s it going to be like in the course of a snowstorm or when the temperature dips to minus 20C?

The line is underground nearer to downtown, however in Scarborough it’s a frozen block of ice. As regular, downtown will get the cream, the suburbs get the transit dregs. Just have a look at how the TTC allowed the Scarborough RT to rot in place till a prepare derailed.

Article content material

Article content material

RECOMMENDED VIDEO

We apologize, however this video has didn’t load.

Play Video

When I used to be writing about this, all the sharp headed transit wonks would tut-tut after I steered an LRT was inappropriate for our metropolis. They stated we couldn’t afford it. They stated gentle rail was the quickest and least expensive to construct. Turns out I used to be proper they usually had been mistaken.

We may have constructed a subway to Ottawa for what we’ve spent on the Finch and Eglinton traces.

And talking of Ottawa, they received an LRT on this planet’s second coldest capital, as a substitute of subways. How’s that understanding? Oh, proper.

Before the LRTs grew to become king, there was no Metrolinx. It was a creation of Dalton McGuinty’s authorities and it metastasized beneath subsequent Liberal governments. One minute it didn’t exist. A few years later, it spawned web page after web page on the Sunshine checklist of individuals making greater than $100,000 a 12 months. Apparently, none of them may work out how you can construct an LRT that truly delivered on time and on finances.

Article content material

RECOMMENDED VIDEO

We apologize, however this video has didn’t load.

Play Video

Years in the past, I recall a colleague telling me about an incident on the listening to into the 1995 subway tragedy, the place three individuals had been killed and 30 others had been injured when two trains collided. A senior supervisor was giving proof on the inquiry and was handed a chunk of kit that was key to the inquiry. He couldn’t clarify the way it labored. Other managers stepped up, however had been equally mystified as to its engineering. Finally, a bit of man in well-worn work overalls sitting on the again received up, picked up the swap and wordlessly demonstrated the way it labored. It stated every little thing it’s worthwhile to know concerning the TTC. The individuals who run it don’t essentially know the way it works.

Over the years, I’ve used the TTC quite a bit to get across the metropolis. I grew up in London, a metropolis that has nice public transit. I realized to navigate the London Underground as a baby. I relied on it to get round. And London constructed subways. Then extra subways. I doubt these snobby transit critics  who appeared down on Rob Ford have been additional than Mississauga.

Article content material

The Eglinton Crosslink took away two lanes of visitors on what was as soon as the town’s quickest east-west route. The configuration is complicated and has poor signage. Before it’s even opened, an individual has died in an accident on the road.

Now we have now no transit and extra congestion. How a lot did they pay all these “specialists” to determine on the LRT when it was apparent we should always have constructed subways?

A examine on the time stated they’d price extra, however within the long-term they had been the appropriate resolution. It was ignored. Rob Ford was mocked. I used to be mocked.

And we ended up with two ineffective transit traces which can be, actually, frozen in time.

Article content material