It could sound anachronistic to make use of phrases like espionage, counterintelligence, secret companies, or double brokers in relation to historical occasions. But actions, organizations, and personnel that largely match our present ideas had been extensively deployed by the civilizations of the traditional world, giving reality to the saying that there’s nothing new beneath the Sun (or, on this case, the shadows).
To present a number of examples: Ramses II was almost defeated on the Battle of Kadesh (which led to a stalemate) attributable to a obtrusive failure by his army intelligence companies and a counterintelligence operation staged by his enemies, the Hittites. The Egyptians captured two Bedouins (who had been really spies) who gave them false, unverified data, main a part of the pharaoh’s military into an ambush by the lethal chariots of Muwatalli II.
The Spartans, for his or her half, developed subtle cryptography methods (the scytale, a cipher consisting of a stick and a strip of leather-based).
As for Alexander the Great, he not solely had an intelligence service that allowed him to advance his military via Asia in full data of precisely the place he was going, however he additionally had — due to secret brokers — an in depth understanding of the interior state of his troops, their morale, and their occasional discontent, in addition to management over the conspiracies brewing round him.
Hannibal was a grasp intelligence gatherer, and his good maneuvers weren’t restricted to the good battles during which he defeated the Romans, akin to Cannae and Trasimene, but additionally prolonged to the realm of espionage and counterintelligence.
Another nice basic of antiquity, Julius Caesar, who used his personal cipher in his communications, deployed a sensational system of army intelligence throughout his conquest of Gaul, together with the launching of a message on a javelin. However, it is also thought-about a mistake to fail to detect the uprisings that might later set the territory ablaze, akin to these of Ambiorix — who destroyed 15 cohorts by offering false data to the Romans — and Vercingetorix (to not point out Caesar’s failure to see the plot coming that might value him his life on the Ides of March).
Without leaving the Roman world, not even the Cambridge Five proved as able to double-dealing because the Cheruscan Arminius, who led the annihilation of the three legions of the legate Publius Quintilius Varus (the clades variana, or “the Varus catastrophe”) within the Teutoburg Forest. The blunder Varus and his intelligence service walked into in ignoring the clear indicators of treason and jeu d’agent, to place it in trendy phrases, and falling into the entice set by their supposed ally was resounding and resulted in one of many best defeats ever inflicted upon the Roman military.
The e book Servicios de inteligencia en la Antigüedad is devoted to exploring a subject that’s each sensational and various (and revolutionary). In its chapters, 17 specialists — together with a number of worldwide authors such because the famend Rosy Mary Shelton, a retired U.S. Army colonel and PhD in Ancient History (which already qualifies her as a double agent), and the quantity’s coordinator, Fernando Bermejo-Rubio, from the Department of Ancient History at UNED, Madrid — analyze varied facets of the phenomenon.
The e book covers espionage within the Egyptian New Kingdom 2,300 years in the past and the extraordinarily efficient Neo-Assyrian intelligence companies (911-612 BC), in addition to intelligence brokers and actions within the Visigothic Kingdom (sixth and seventh centuries), whereas additionally inspecting the companies of the Persian Empire and the Greek, Hellenistic, and Roman worlds.
Of specific observe are the surprising chapters dedicated to spies, the key police, and brokers provocateurs in historical India, and to the environment friendly intelligence service operated by Herod the Great and his dynasty in his small consumer kingdom of Judea, Galilee, Samaria, and Idumea. Figures akin to John the Baptist (no, Salome wasn’t his nemesis) and maybe Jesus of Nazareth himself fell into the nets of his son Herod Antipas. It’s price remembering that within the turbulent Jewish panorama, there’s one other main determine who could possibly be thought-about a double agent: the defector Flavius Josephus, the stunning escape artist from Jotapata.
As is usually the case in a collaborative e book, the chapters are very disparate in scope and elegance, with some weighed down by an extra of educational zeal and others a little bit unfocused. However, the general work is fascinating and clearly demonstrates — as Bermejo-Rubio (who additionally wrote the introduction) emphasizes in a dialog with this newspaper — not solely the existence of intelligence actions in historical occasions, lengthy earlier than the emergence of the fashionable states with which we affiliate them, but additionally their excessive degree of complexity and refinement, in some circumstances larger than one may assume.
“Neither Alexander nor Caesar, for instance, would have been in a position to obtain their feats with out informants and spies,” he displays. In this regard, the compiler notes that “it has rightly been stated that the work of a spy within the service of energy might problem the glory of being the oldest career on this planet.”
Bermejo-Rubio, who factors out that the e book is being revealed within the wake of the primary worldwide convention on intelligence actions within the historical world (2023), emphasizes the problem of discovering documentation on all these actions — which embody covert operations, focused assassinations, and fifth-columnism — given their secret and infrequently clandestine nature, along with the passage of time. “Sometimes we have now to depend on small clues, however, quoting Momigliano, no much less critical than discovering issues the place they don’t exist is inferring that one thing doesn’t exist simply because we will’t discover any proof.”
The e book opens with the chapter Spies, Informants and Border Controls in New Kingdom Egypt, during which the Valencian Egyptologist José Lull examines, in sources such because the Amarna letters, data actions on the borders, police (medjay), or the interrogation of prisoners, and explains intimately the Hittite disinformation operation in Qadesh — the Egyptians prevented catastrophe by capturing two haputi (sic), explorers or spies, enemies who beneath torture confessed the true place of their military. The pharaohs relied on people categorized because the “eyes and ears of the king,” a title that additionally seems within the Achaemenid Persian world.
Francisco Giannone, a analysis physician on the Sorbonne, addresses the “intense and systematic” espionage and intelligence exercise within the Ancient Near East in the course of the second millennium BC, particularly in Mari and Hattusa (the Hittite capital). He attests to the process of issuing false orders to messengers and entrusting the true report back to a pill, and the follow of mutilation and elimination by the state of people thought-about problematic.
In Mari, brokers had been referred to as sa lisanim, “long-tongued males,” or nasrum, “secret man,” and sapasalli, (spy) in Hittite. The Neo-Assyrian intelligence companies, as Assyriologist Peter Dubovsky discusses, had been extraordinarily expert in psychological and anti-subversive warfare beneath Sargon II, and though he considers that they didn’t represent, as has been stated, a real deuxième bureau — an autonomous intelligence workplace — the scholar compares them as techniques typical of totalitarianism with the Soviet NKVD and KGB and the Czechoslovak StB, reasonably than with the CIA and MI6. Among the circumstances introduced by Dubovsky is that of the kidnapping of the son of a king who refused to collaborate with the Assyrians, in an effort to stress him.
Joaquín Velázquez, a physician in historical past from the Complutense University of Madrid, writes concerning the intelligence companies of the Achaemenid Persians, important in such an enormous empire and which relied on the categorical messengers often called pyrradazzi. He praises the army intelligence harvested by Cyrus the Great and extends it to his son Cambyses II and his conquest of Egypt, which is stunning provided that he was able to shedding a complete military by taking the mistaken instructions to the Siwa Oasis. We should additionally keep in mind Xerxes’ wonderful use of the double agent Ephialtes, the traitor at Thermopylae.
In the aforementioned chapter on historical India, the Sanskritist Francisco Javier Rubio Orecilla highlights the use, illustrated within the Ramayana and Mahabharata, of undercover brokers, typically within the guise of snake charmers and wandering ascetics (echoed in Kipling’s Kim), bribery, homicide, and using intercourse to acquire data, à la Profumo.
One of essentially the most thought-provoking texts within the assortment is by Fernando Echeverría, professor of historical historical past on the Complutense University of Madrid, who analyzes the idea of data in Greece and means that the Sirens within the Odyssey are extra informants than the rest, representing, he says, the Greek suspicions of informants. The legendary Ulysses, in fact, might be seen as an awesome gatherer and supervisor of intelligence, along with showing as a spy within the Trojan camp within the Iliad alongside Diomedes. And isn’t the episode of the horse an instance of a covert operation and infiltration, swapping Black Hawks for the wood beast?
In any case, within the chapter by U.S. historian and classicist Frank Russell, we see the deployment of spy-scouts (skopoi), brokers and informants within the Peloponnesian War, and the scholar factors out one thing very curious: that the idea of Greek intelligence should embody manteia, divination, such because the oracular pronouncements on the sanctuary of Delphi.
Although the world of Greek intelligence — leaving apart the Macedonian companies, that are addressed by Adolfo J. Domínguez Monedero, professor of historical historical past on the Autonomous University of Madrid, in his chapter — is portrayed within the e book as unprofessional in comparison with different civilizations (it’s famous that espionage was seen as amoral in Athenian democracy), one can’t assist however consider the disinformation practiced by Themistocles at Salamis or the tips and underhandedness of Alcibiades.
In Cases of Maneuvers and Military Intelligence within the Second Punic War, UNED historian Sabino Perea Yébenes evaluations Hannibal’s deserves in acquiring data from the enemy, considers that the Carthaginians had been higher ready for the sort of warfare and operations (a Punic spy spent two years in Rome earlier than being found), and debates the speculation that Scipio Africanus was the inventor of Roman espionage, or not less than the final who systematically used it to counter the “soiled“ strategies — the well-known Punic perfidy — of their rival. In psychological warfare, the Romans shortly caught up, as evidenced by the catapult launching of his brother Hasdrubal’s head into Hannibal’s camp after the latter’s victory at Metaurus, exactly as a result of he had intercepted a letter from him.
The research Intelligence Services within the Works of Julius Caesar by Denis Álvarez Pérez-Sostoa, a classicist from the University of the Basque Country; Internal Security in Early Principate Rome, or How to Kill an Emperor by Rose Mary Sheldon; and Information Gathering within the Provinces by Juan José Palao Vicente from the University of Salamanca, totally immerse us on this planet of espionage and secret operations in historical Rome, from the late Republic to the High Empire. This was the world of exploratores, speculatores, and frumentarii (brokers in rebus from the time of Constantine, as famous by historian Raúl González Salinero), typically specialised troopers tasked with shadowy duties that included infiltration, conspiracy detection, and even assassination.
Margarita Vallejo, professor of historical historical past on the University of Alcalá, contributes a chapter on intelligence companies within the Eastern Roman Empire (fifth to seventh centuries). The Romans, Sheldon factors out, didn’t have a central intelligence and safety establishment just like the FBI or the CIA, and these brokers typically overlapped with the Praetorian Guard. The scholar emphasizes that regardless of the similarities we typically see between the U.S. and historical Rome, Roman leaders had been by no means murdered by a lone murderer…
Sign up for our weekly e-newsletter to get extra English-language information protection from EL PAÍS USA Edition
