EXPERT OPINION / PERSPECTIVE — Reports from Moscow counsel that U.S. representatives Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff are “optimistic” in regards to the prospect of outcomes from their dialogue with Kremlin officers this week. But after months of fruitless negotiations, if they’re optimistic about reaching a negotiated resolution to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, they’ve little cause for it, given feedback from Russian officers on the Moscow discussions.
If, as has been just lately recommended to me, a central precedence behind Kusher and Witkoff’s participation in negotiations (as a substitute of counting on extra skilled U.S. diplomats with a report of coping with autocrats like Vladimir Putin) is to safe enterprise offers in Russia following the conclusion of hostilities, then each the negotiations over Ukraine’s future and future enterprise offers in Russia will show to be idiot’s errands, the previous first and the latter over time. President Trump ought to know higher and will have chosen higher illustration for U.S. pursuits.
Kremlin spokesman Dmitriy Peskov described the assembly between Putin and the U.S. representatives as “very helpful, constructive, and extremely substantive.” At the identical time, he stated no compromise on a peace plan was reached. He went on to notice that Russia desires peace, however provided that its goals are met and reiterated that Moscow insists on reaching the objectives of its “particular operation.”
Peskov’s remarks are usually not shocking as they’re fully in step with the narrative that Putin has pushed earlier than and through his ill-fated invasion of Ukraine. As if to emphasise the Kremlin’s rejection of the Kushner-Witkoff mission, Putin launched one of many largest drone and missile assaults on Ukraine, most likely whereas the U.S. representatives had been nonetheless within the air flying house.
Russia’s place on this “negotiation” is completely clear and has been for a while: The full elimination of Ukraine as an unbiased nation; the breakup of the transatlantic alliance which has been the bedrock of European safety since 1945; the creation and exacerbation of political division within the United States to weaken it as a strategic opponent and create the situations for the institution of a multi-polar world order with Moscow and Beijing main the autocratic anti-democratic poles and a weakened U.S. and Europe, the opposite pole. Success in Ukraine is vital to Putin and Chinese President Xi Jingping’s technique.
As a part of the pink orchestra Putin is directing to set the stage for the achievement of his goals, he’s pushing two important narratives. The first is that Russia can obtain by army conquest the subjugation of Ukraine – the narrative that Kyiv is shedding and can inevitably lose the conflict. Secondly, he’s pushing the argument in Washington and elsewhere that Europe is undermining the Trump Administration’s efforts to realize a negotiated resolution to the battle (nevertheless feckless and unrealistic the 28 level peace plan was/is). Putin can also be utilizing a mix of “grey zone” clandestine kinetic and deadly operations throughout Europe to undermine public confidence of their safety at house and undermine resolve to assist Ukraine and resist Putin’s ambitions. The Russian chief has executed a lot of these efforts lately with various levels of believable deniability and positively with none retribution or consequence paid.
Subscriber+Members are invited to hitch in an unique digital dialog on Monday, December 8 at 2:30p ET on Russia’s Gray Zone Operations in Europe with former leaders from the Department of Defense, CIA, NATO and the British Foreign Office. Members obtain hyperlinks to register by way of electronic mail.
Not a Subscriber+Member? Let’s repair that.
At Putin’s age and at this stage of his regime, he can’t again off his maximalist goals in Ukraine, not less than not till the ache from the conflict is felt by Russian elites and the Russian public to the purpose the place his home of playing cards begins to tumble.
Ukraine’s capability to extract most casualties from Russia’s marginal territorial advances in Ukraine plus the price being paid by Ukraine’s long-range strikes in opposition to vitality infrastructure and army targets within the Russian Federation begin to undermine assist in these constituencies for Putin’s continued governance. The plan led by Kushner and Witkoff and endorsed by Trump works in opposition to undermining assist in Russia for Putin’s aggression.
So, the place does that go away Kushner and Witkoff with regard to a rumored undisclosed agenda of utilizing the negotiations as cowl for post-conflict enterprise preparations with Moscow? Dealing with enterprise confidence in a kleptocracy is an oxymoron. If Kushner and Witkoff have by no means heard of Bill Browder, they need to look him up.
Browder has persistently and precisely described the dangers of doing enterprise in Putin’s Russia. He once more just lately identified these dangers within the particular context of warning Trump and his representatives of the chance they’re taking up. Browder’s cogent observations and the wreckage of the a whole bunch of U.S. and western companies that poured into Russia after the collapse of the Soviet Union present you could put cash in however getting it out is one other matter completely.
Who’s Reading this? More than 500K of essentially the most influential nationwide safety specialists on this planet. Need full entry to what the Experts are studying?
Trump and his representatives appear to assume they would be the exception to the Russian kleptocratic paradigm. They won’t be.
One may be positive Putin and Dmitriev will likely be whispering all the guarantees into the ears of their U.S. interlocutors. Kushner and Witkoff will dutifully carry these messages again to the White House and share their pipe dream fantasies of the untold riches of being on Putin’s good aspect.
The solely factor Putin asks Kushner and Witkoff to relay is that Trump cease aiding and supporting the 2 remaining obstacles to a negotiated settlement, Zelensky and the European members of NATO. End army, intelligence, and financial help to Ukraine, Putin definitely could have stated, and Ukrainian resistance will collapse speedily, and the conflict will introduced extra quickly to its inevitable conclusion. And the U.S. definitely ought to have the ability to put sufficient strain on its NATO puppets to finish their futile assist for Ukraine and there will likely be peace in our time.
The President ought to have interaction some sound and skilled counsel to offer extra reasonable and skilled steering on Russian realities. The first little bit of that counsel can be to take away any phantasm that Putin is a person who may be trusted. Putin’s private and non-private feedback in addition to his actions over the twenty plus years he has been operating the Russian Federation go away little doubt as to the place he stands with regard to the West normally and the U.S. particularly.
He believes democracy and capitalism are outmoded and morally exhausted political and financial philosophies doomed to break down. As President of the nation to which Putin refers because the “glavniy protivnik” or essential enemy, President Trump ought to notice in Putin’s thoughts, HE is the primary enemy.
Any guarantees of enterprise offers that can observe the conclusion of the Ukraine battle will inevitably be damaged by Putin and his representatives. President Trump ought to perceive Putin desires to steal his cash essentially the most. What higher victory for Putin than to have the U.S. hand him victory in Ukraine and within the course of arrange the largest theft of cash from a U.S. entity in historical past.
A second little bit of counsel President Trump may search to offer his representatives is that it is vitally tough to maintain secret offers secret when you find yourself represented by somebody as manifestly incompetent and compromised as Steve Witkoff. No further proof must be offered than the leaked transcript of the decision with Kirill Dmitriev during which Witkoff gives recommendation on how one can persuade President Trump to just accept the Russian proposals for the top of the battle in Ukraine.
In addition to the naiveté of getting such a dialog within the first place, Witkoff must also be suggested that enterprise such actions appears loads like he’s appearing as an agent of affect for the Russian Federation.
Lastly, President Trump needs to be reminded of former British Prime Minister Winston Churchill’s well-known remarks to Neville Chamberlain after Munich, “You got the selection between dishonor and conflict. You selected dishonor and you should have conflict.” In the context of the present negotiations Churchill might need added {that a} idiot and his cash are quickly parted.
All statements of reality, opinion, or evaluation expressed are these of the writer and don’t replicate the official positions or views of the U.S. Government. Nothing within the contents needs to be construed as asserting or implying U.S. Government authentication of knowledge or endorsement of the writer’s views.
The Cipher Brief is dedicated to publishing a variety of views on nationwide safety points submitted by deeply skilled nationwide safety professionals.
Opinions expressed are these of the writer and don’t symbolize the views or opinions of The Cipher Brief.
Have a perspective to share primarily based in your expertise within the nationwide safety area? Send it to Editor@thecipherbrief.com for publication consideration.
Read extra expert-driven nationwide safety insights, perspective and evaluation in The Cipher Brief
